Photo: rossograph / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0
Evanston residents asked what the city should do with three of its biggest buildings mostly gave the same kind of answer: housing. On Monday, City Council will hear the top ideas from a year of outreach and decide how narrowly consultants should focus before they write a final plan.
A memo in the Nov. 23 council packet from Economic Development Manager Paul Zalmezak says residents submitted nearly 100 proposals through ward meetings, one-on-one outreach and the EvanstonPAW.org crowdsourcing site. The leading ideas, by votes:
- Morton Civic Center, 2100 Ridge Ave.: convert the building to residential use. Returning it to civic use ranked second.
- Police and Fire Headquarters: move police and fire operations elsewhere and redevelop the property with housing.
- Noyes Cultural Arts Center: expand arts programming and explore mixed-use development, including parking, on the surface lots next door.
Nothing is being sold or moved yet. The item is listed for discussion only, and the memo frames it as setting a framework for an eventual disposition process. Still, it is the clearest look so far at where public opinion sits on three large public properties, including the headquarters of the police and fire departments and the city’s arts center.
Why the city is asking now
The effort is called Putting Assets to Work. Council adopted the city’s PAW guide in April 2024. It flagged the three buildings, 13 city-owned surface parking lots and lakefront amenities as places where Evanston might find “hidden value” or revenue rather than relying solely on taxes or outside aid. The memo describes the model as an alternative to privatization, meant to build community wealth and advance goals like affordable housing and climate resilience.
In November 2024, council accepted a $985,000 grant from the U.S. Department of Transportation’s Innovative Finance and Asset Concession Grant program, run through the Build America Bureau. The money pays for analysis, consultants and community engagement on the three buildings. The grant language describes 2100 Ridge as a potential mixed-use hub, the police and fire headquarters as a candidate for relocation and reuse, and Noyes as a site for better programming, accessibility and mixed-use options. Financing tools under study include public-private partnerships and federal Transportation Infrastructure Finance and Innovation Act loans.
That money is limited, and staff wants to stop spreading it thin. Rather than run full financial feasibility tests on every idea residents sent in, the memo recommends narrowing the list. Staff is asking council which parameters matter most for the deeper modeling: preferred uses, building height and density, the mix of unit sizes and affordability levels, how much commercial space to include and how much parking to require.
What comes after Monday
The PAW consulting team is scheduled to present its engagement and feasibility findings at the meeting. Council’s direction will shape a final Recommended Action Plan, which staff expects to bring back in the first quarter of 2027.
The conversation comes during an expensive season at City Hall. The same Nov. 23 agenda includes final votes on the city’s 2027 budget and tax levies, which advanced on a 5-4 vote earlier this month, and on the Evanston Public Library’s levy, covered in our story on the library’s 2027 budget. Council also recently approved a 26-story tower at 900 Clark St., a sign of how much of the housing debate is now playing out downtown.
Council meets at 5:30 p.m. Monday at Lorraine H. Morton City Hall, 909 Davis St., and online via Zoom and the city’s Channel 16. Residents can sign up to speak or submit written comment through the City Clerk’s office before the meeting. More city coverage is on our Local News page.
Add The Evanston Edge as a preferred source on Google (opens in a new tab)
Margaret Whitfield is the editor of The Evanston Edge and covers local government, development and neighborhoods.
More Local News

THE HOLIDAY TREE FARM BY LANDS’ END BRINGS THE SPIRIT OF THE SEASON TO CHICAGO FOR ONE FESTIVE WEEKEND

Luxor® Workspaces Puts Smarter Device Management in the Spotlight with Kwik IQ® Hub Debut at Connected Worker Summit
